Temple Law Logo TU Portal

Topics

Affirmative Action for Law Scholarship

There are several issues in this unfolding story about Scholastica, law review submissions, and “diversity” preferences. Let’s break them out.

I’m shocked!  Shocked!:  Over at Prawfs, Professor Mannheimer and various anonymous commentators think that Orin, Josh and I are naive.  Everyone knows that law reviews routinely take race, gender and sexual orientation into account when choosing between articles.  Indeed, Josh got an email from a former editor at the California Law Review saying that the practice “is nothing new and not exactly a secret.” Well, shucks. I guess I’m the sucker here.  Even if this had crossed my mind, I would have naively thought that law faculties would never permit law student boards to make decisions about articles based on race, gender and sexual orientation without clearly thinking through [...]

Via Concurring Opinions

Posted Under :

0 Comments :

Comment

Comments closed